Here's one last John Philips-winning entry, in response to a post about Jose Feliciano singing the national anthem at Shea last week - and much more controversially at Tiger Stadium during the '68 World Series.
John, we love you and hope you keep posting comments forever, but it's time for other people to have a chance. You've retired the original WatchDog Comment Contest Trophy.
Here it is: "I've seen the kinescope of the broadcast. Jose was introduced and played in center field. When he was finished, Ernie Harwell and Curt Gowdy said nothing, NBC went to commercial, and the game started.
"My grandmother reacted much differently. Not a sports fan herself, she walked into the room where my grandfather was watching. He was almost deaf at this point in his life and he always turned his hearing aid off during the anthem, so he heard nothing. Grandma did hear it however. The result was a rare mid day long distance call to my mother. This was in the day when long distance was actually expensive and such a phone call from grandmother led my mother believe that something bad had happened to my grandfather.
"Instead, mom heard about the decline of western civilization as symbolized by Feliciano's national anthem. Usually Grandma used a three minute egg timer to limit her long distance expenditures, but on this day, my mother remembered her going two egg timers worth. A few months later, Jose appeared on the Glen Campbell Good Time Hour, one of Grandma's favorite shows.
"After seeing Jose Feliciano mentioned in the opening credits, Glen Campbell joined her growing list of entertainment non entities and the Good Time Hour was never watched again. The late 60's were hard on Grandma. How she ever managed to survive living through World Wars I and II, I'll never know."