Our faithful blog readers have made several interesting posts on Giambi and his past trangressions, so let's stick to the topic and address the comments.
***
You know what, who cares about Giambi? The guy basically admitted he cheated. He DIDN'T apologize for it, no matter how you spin it. I'll root for Bernie, Jeter, even A-Rod and Damon. But not for a guy who told a grand jury he cheated to win. That's where I draw the line. Get off his bandwagon.
-- shelly
You have every right to choose to cheer for someone else instead because of Giambi's past, and I commend you for that. It's impressive that your opinion has not been swayed by Giambi's monster second half last season, and his strong start to the first half.
***
Giambi is certainly having an outstanding season offensively. But the guy is a "butcher" at 1st base. The Yanks should promote and play Carlos Pena at 1st base, Giambi moves to D.H., and Bernie Williams to the bench as a 4th outfielder and pinch-hitter. If the Yanks don't want to promote Pena, then Cairo would be my choice at 1st base. Cairo is a very good player wasting away on the bench.
-- Roy Storing
Can't argue with you here. Pena has a great glove, and Bernie hasn't been all that consistent with the bat, so makes sense. The only risk you run is that Giambi has it in his head that he does better at the plate when he plays the field. And the numbers back him up. Yet somewhere down the line Giambi will become a full-time DH, and it will be interesting to see whether he embraces it. As for Cairo, yes, he's a fine player, but Andy Phillips has to get a regular shot before Cairo does. Besides, Cairo is the only middle infielder on the bench.
***
I really wish people like the first responder* to your blog would quit harping on the "non-apology" apology. Legally, he knew he'd be in possible breach if he said exactly what he was apologizing for. Everybody knew what he was talking about, and would be foolish if they didn't. In that situation, Giambi did what anyone else would do. I swear, sometimes I think people lose at least 30 IQ points when it comes to sports.
-- cw
I'll assume CW doesn't stand for Chien-Ming Wang. Anyway, onto Giambi's apology/non-apology. I understand why some fans wanted more. Heck, it would have been really awesome to hear someone of his stature stand up there and say "Yes, I did it. I apologize to everyone because I cheated the game and took steroids." But as you correctly pointed out, there was no way Giambi was going to do that. The Yankees would have immediately jumped onto that admission and went to court trying to void the $82 million left on his contract. So he did what he could, said as much as he could without putting his money at risk. We all wanted more, but it's understandable why he didn't give more. As you pointed out, 99.9 percent of people would have done the same thing with that much money coming to them.
***
Jason Giambi....the walking, talking VERY bulked up pinstriped steriod... does ANYBODY remember what this guy looked like last season ...he looked like walking death!! That HR he hit off of Schilling..if you saw the replay he didn't even take a