In the process of reporting this story in today's Newsday, Astros owner Drayton McLane told me that he and team president Tal Smith met with Roger Clemens and his agents, Alan and Randy Hendricks, last December, following the release of the Mitchell Report.
The issue about Clemens pitching in 2008 came up. "They were totally undecided," McLane said. "They said they'd let us know when they were ready to talk."
That meeting took place before Clemens' case snowballed into the monster it is now, of course. At that time, it seemed feasible that Clemens could make a go at another half-season, especially back in the National League, after his 2007 with the Yankees left some people disappointed. And hey, there are Mitchell Report perpetrators all over the major leagues. The Astros shortstop, Miguel Tejada, is being investigated by the U.S. Department of Justice for perjury, just like Clemens.
Now, however, you can probably bet against such a comeback. A person close to Clemens told me that a fifth "unretirement" seems very unlikely, since Clemens is battling multiple battles with the DOJ investigation, the defamation lawsuit against Brian McNamee and the reports dealing with his infidelitities.
Gotta run right now. I'll try to check in later with more...
UPDATE, 12:54 p.m.: Very sorry about that. I intended to start this blog last night, after the Mets game, but I fell asleep around the fifth inning. So I didn't have enough time this morning, and I had to take my son to school and run a few errands...yada yada yada. Here I am.
Back to Clemens, it sounds like it's for the best that he's retiring. The Yankees can't take him back, not after they were hurt more than anyone else by the Mitchell Report, and not with Andy Pettitte in their clubhouse. As for the Astros, McLane wouldn't rule out bringing back Clemens, but it sounded like a longshot.
"I think a lot needs to develop, in my opinion," McLane said. "I think there's got to be a lot of questions answered."
When asked, in a follow-up e-mail, what those questions would be, McLane responded, "1) Does Roger want to pitch again; 2) What will result from the congressional investigation; 3) What are the Houston Astros’ needs, etc."
The answer to number 1 appears to be "No." Number 2 could take years to answer. As for number 3, the Astros would certainly be a better team with Clemens taking the ball every fifth day. But it appears to be a moot issue.
I was chatting with one of Newsday's copy editors, Greg Gutes, yesterday, and we were wondering how much better off Clemens would've been if, the day the Mitchell Report was released, he put out a statement confirming the illegal PED usage, with something like, "As a competitor, I couldn't handle not being the best anymore, so I bought into the culture at the time. I wish I could do it all over again."
Greg thinks that Clemens would be in dramatically better shape. I think that he would still be in pretty bad shape. Obviously, Clemens' family wouldn't have been dragged into this, but his Hall of Fame candidacy, and his status as one of the best pitchers of all-time, would be shattered nonetheless. Thoughts?
When I watch Mets pitching coach Rick Peterson shake his head after Oliver Perez does something stupid, which is pretty frequent, I think of this episode of "The Simpsons," when the federal agent tries, repeatedly, to explain to Homer that his new name will be "Mr. Thompson."
Agent: Tell you what, sir. From now on, you'll be, uh, Homer Thompson
at Terror Lake. Let's just practice a bit, hmm? When I say,
"Hello, Mr. Thompson," you'll say, "Hi."
Homer: Check.
Agent: Hello, Mr. Thompson.
Homer: [stares blankly]
Agent: Remember now, your name is Homer Thompson.
Homer: I gotcha.
Agent: Hello, Mr. Thompson.
Homer: [stares blankly]
[A long time later]
Agent: [sighs in frustration] Now, when I say, "Hello, Mr. Thompson,"
and press down on your foot, you smile and nod.
Homer: No problem.
Agent: Hello, Mr. Thompson! [stomps on Homer's foot a few times]
Homer: [stares blankly]
[to other agent] I think he's talking to _you_.
Any team that signs Perez to a long-term contract this winter is out of its mind.
On the bright side, Mets fans, is that Carlos Delgado really appears to be waking up. Right now, if faced with this debate, I'd have to say that, right now, Jason Giambi is hurting the Yankees more than Delgado is hurting the Mets.
That was the first time I had seen Chad Billingsley pitch. Impressive. Joe Torre has a pretty talented team out there. I'm feeling all right about my "Dodgers NL wild-card" prediction.
Thanks to this site for the photo.