The $1,000 down payment program at Continental Home Loans lives on borrowed time, but the Melville company’s chief, Mike McHugh, knew his idea might have a short life.
He started the program about eight months ago, but now, the crux of the idea - seller-funded down payment funneled through nonprofits – will no longer be legal on loans backed by the Federal Housing Administration, which requires up to a 3 percent minimum down payment for buyers, depending on the FHA program. The Housing and Economic Recovery Act, signed into law last month, bars such seller-funded down payments on new FHA-backed loans starting Oct. 1.
So far, the $1,000-down program has led to about 100 or so home sales as well as closings under other loan programs, McHugh said. “The product itself got them interested and maybe gave them the impetus to go look at a house and say ‘Yeah, I can do this,’ “ he said.
But using housing nonprofits to funnel help from sellers has been controversial. Lenders around the country have been getting around the minimum down payment rule when sellers agree to help on down payment to lure buyers. Sellers to “donate” money to the nonprofit, which would then “grant” the money to the buyer and also get a donation that it keeps from the seller.
FHA said this practice led to inflated prices and higher default rates. It tried to shut down that practice but was sued by the nonprofits last year.
McHugh, who said his $1,000 program sought qualified buyers, believes there should be seller-funded help on down payments but also thinks there should be restrictions, including higher credit scores for such buyers as a way of limiting risks.
Some lawmakers agree and have already introduced bills to allow seller-funded assistance on FHA loans.
Continental’s chief said he’s got about 30 to 40 loans in the pipeline to be approved. He’s sent interested buyers, sellers, agents and others in the program emails and letters about the Oct. 1 deadline; the loans have to be approved by then but the closings can take place later.
McHugh’s doesn’t think Congress will pass any change before the new law’s provision kicks in, but he’s optimistic his $1,000 down program will come back to life one day.
“Do I think it’s the end?” he said. “No, I don’t think it’s the end. There’ll be something to take its place somewhere down the road. Our point is if it’s done well, it can be a viable program.”