Immigration nonpolicy
Depending on your personal perspective, our immigration policy regime -- currently a hodgepodge of federal, state, and local law enforcement measures mixed with populist impulses -- is too lax, unjustifiably harsh or nonexistent. So is it working? Depends on how you define success.
A conservative think tank in Washington has taken a stab at evaluating the current approach to immigration enforcement by trying to measure its impact on illegal immigration. The Center for Immigration Studies, which advocates for more immigration restrictions, used various government data sources to calculate change in the undocumented population from August 2007 to May 2008. The study found a roughly 11 percent drop, and researchers speculate the trend is tied to increased immigration enforcement.
But the study has attracted criticism from other immigration experts, who say it is skewed by methodological flaws and overgeneralizations about the dynamics of migration and immigrant communities.

