There's a reason why The Skids' punk rave "The Saints Are Coming" never became a hit. Actually, there are many reasons, not the least of which is that it is quite an ordinary song. However, put U2 and Green Day on it and turn it into a bash-it-out anthem to raise cash for the building of post-Katrina New Orleans culture and the surrounding emotion overcomes its limitations -- a metaphor for not only what The Edge's Music Rising charity is trying to do, but for the careers of both bands involved. "The Saints Are Coming" is passion over substance, but U2 and Green Day still make it work.
The real discovery from their Superdome set, though, is the new version of "Wake Me Up When September Ends," which becomes more regal-sounding and indisputable thanks to The Edge's guitar atmospherics and a huge horn section.
Watch the video here (RealPlayer needed)
Buy "The Saints Are Coming" here (Proceeds go to Music Rising, a charity that helps New Orleans musicians replace their instruments lost in Hurricane Katrina)