Went joyriding in a friend's SUV the other day and got a taste of Pop2K on Sirius XM Satellite Radio. Their Web site claims it's a pop music station full of hits from 2000-08, yet it sounded a heck of lot like Backspin, the old school rap station that almost made purchasing radio in the car worthwhile.
But we can debate that later. Right now, it's time for another debate.
The playlist for my time in the ride went like this:
"Fight the Power" by Public Enemy (1989)
"Go Cut Creator Go" by LL Cool J (1987)
"You Be Illin'" by Run-DMC (1986)
"The What" by Notorious B.I.G. and Method Man (1994)
Can't argue with any of those song choices in terms of good stuff to listen to when driving. But the Biggie selection struck me.
Can we really consider the music of Notorious B.I.G. "old school"? I've been struggling with this topic for a few days now. What defines old school? Is it simply just music that has been out for a long time? Or is it more of a sound and style of rap? Is there a cutoff date for music that is old school and music that is just old?
I would consider anything from Run-DMC in the 1980s to be old school, but I wouldn't call the single "Down With the King" from 1993 old school. It has a different sound. Still, it's a great song. Just an old one, though, not old school. But it's Run-DMC, so do we just classify everything they do as old school because "they were the Beatles of rap" as Chuck D has often called them?
It has been 14 years since Notorious B.I.G. read up Word Up Magazine on his debut album "Ready to Die." That's quite a bit of time, but does that automatically mean it's old school rap music? I say no, at least not by the way I define old school. I say it's just great old music.
To me, old school rap is more of a sound and style than something tied to a front and back ends of a calendar. Kurtis Blow, Slick Rick, Run-DMC, Whodini, Grandmaster Flash, to name a few.
On occasion, we have artists who last long enough to disrupt the time-space continuum that Doc Brown warned us about in "Back to the Future." LL Cool J comes to mind. "Radio," "Bigger and Deffer" and "Walking Like a Panther" are clearly old school rap albums. "Around the Way Girl," as much as I love that song is not old school, just old.
Maybe it's feasible to have more than one category of old school. Or do we just lump it all in one group and let people figure it out on their own?
This is one question, in my mind, that is tougher than leather. What's your take on it? Is Biggie old school or just old?
(Newsday File Photo, 1994 / Stan Honda)